Scorched Earth by GLM and Qwen

GLM 5.2 Max vs Qwen 3.8 Max.
Prompt 1:
Make a single HTML file video game like the original turn-based artillery game Scorched Earth.  Try to make it look like the original MS-DOS version from 1991, and make sure to have both a player vs player mode, and a player vs computer mode.

Result:
GLM won round 1.  Qwen graphics were out of focus, and the animation felt a little more modern, which here is not good.  GLM much was more clear, and period correct.  Qwen also goes to the shop screen after every exchange which is unwanted.

Within arena.ai's web display, GLM was selected as the winner, and from there the harness feeds that as the correct base to build from to both models for subsequent prompts.

Prompt 2:

This is really good, but can you change four things:

  1. Make it so in Play vs Computer, the computer buys its own weapons.
  2. Make the computer player a little less accurate in easy mode.  Seems to be hitting at almost 100%, dial it down to about 50.
  3. Make the differences between the different sized weapons a little larger.
  4. In the scorched earth shop screen, there is flashing white text at the bottom that I cannot read because it is a few pixels below the bottom cutoff.  Can you fix only that.  The rest of the game, and menus display perfectly.

Result:

Almost identical, but the GLM version feels a little more balanced, and fonts look a little clearer.  Tie goes to GLM for continuity, and cohesion as the base author.

Prompt 3:

This is almost perfect in a desktop browser, but it needs a full screen option.  It also needs to work in a mobile browser.  You should be able to start the game by tapping, or clicking a start button.  The game controls should appear as icons you can tap when in a mobile browser.

Result:

GLM wins with a bigger screen, and clearer controls.

Prompt 4:

Very good.  The desktop view is now perfect.  The only change I request is to slow down the angle, and power adjustment by about 2x.  Right now even very small taps move the number by more than one, so dialing in an exact number is difficult.
In mobile only, make the shop text twice as large, and add scrolling to fit all weapons.  Also in mobile only make the angle, and power display twice as large.

GLM wins, store menue better, but new display box did block the main game.  Qwen just made existing field bigger, which is exactly what was asked for, but probably not as good.  But if I had to pick a V4 to play vs a V4 to turn into V5, Qwen would win here.

Prompt 5:

Desktop version is now perfect.
Mobile version is almost perfect.
In the mobile version only, move the new ANG and PWR display box to the left outside the main playing screen like the rest of the mobile only controls are.  It currently blocks the main playing display, and that's sometimes a big problem.

GLM perfect.  Qwen vertically expanded the mobile control display grid, and shrank the main playing field.

Prompt 6:

Almost there.
Desktop is still perfect.
Mobile shrank the main playing canvas, which should never happen.  In mobile only, move the ANG and PWR numbers to the top left next to the FULL SCREEN button, and don't use anymore vertical pixels than are currently used by those above canvas buttons.  And move the POWER METER to the left of the canvas displayed vertically, making certain not to shrink the playing canvas.

GLM numbers more clear, power meter tighter to canvas, should maximize canvas on any mobile screen.

SCORCHED EARTH - DOS Artillery Tribute
F1 HELP  ·  F9 SCANLINES  ·  ←→ ANGLE  ·  ↑↓ POWER  ·  Q/W WEAPON  ·  , . DRIVE  ·  SPACE FIRE  ·  MOUSE-DRAG TO AIM